Thursday, November 29, 2012

AP drops 'homophobia'

I have been arguing for some time that it is inappropriate to label most forms of anti-gay (speech) acts as homophobic. The reason being essentially that phobias are anxiety disorders. Most of the actions described today as homophobic are simply anti-gay, those undertaking them are fully competent and the actions they engage in are not in any way expressions of anxiety disorders. Labelling them as homophobic suggests limited personal responsibility for their actions, because of the anxiety disorder link. 

I am delighted therefore that the Associated Press, in its revised style guide, asks journalists to refrain from using the term 'homophobic' or 'homophobia' precisely because these terms mislabel anti-gay actions, and because they suggest limited responsibility on the part of those who engage in anti-gay manners. AP Deputy Standards Editor Dave Minthorn explains, 'Homophobia especially -- it's just off the mark. It's ascribing a mental disability to someone, and suggests a knowledge that we don't have. It seems inaccurate. Instead, we would use something more neutral: anti-gay, or some such, if we had reason to believe that was the case.'

3 comments:

  1. Do you oppose photophobia as well, because we're using a word syntactically describing an irrational fear of photography, to label people whose eyes are pained by light? This is just one category of phobias that have nothing to do with fear.

    A second category includes "hydrophobic", which can describe a fear of water (usually "aquaphobic"), but more commonly means a substance that repels water. It also means rabid. And it has a partner "oleophobic" (repelling oil). And "myrmecophobic" things repel ants.

    The third category is what you and the AP object to, but it's long-established, even in atheism. There's atheophobia (fear or hatred of atheists), use of which is increasing in popularity recently, but has been in print since at least 1843. Francophobia (or Gallophobia) is dislike or hatred of France (one or the other term has been used for centuries). "Xenophobia" is in this category, with the dreaded "homophobia".

    I think it's wiser to accept long-standing usage of the suffix -phobia, rather than trying to deny it and censor it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I hear you Randy, my problem is that when it is used as a campaign tool (ie painting those wo are anti-gay as phobic in the clinical sense) it can easily backfire. Think of gay panic attack in court cases. It absolves those who are virulently antigay to some extent of responsibility for their actions. I do think of that as a strategic mistake. I also think it does a disservice to those who actually suffer from phobias. One shouldn't import clinical terminology into political campaigns to score points. My take on the issue.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello all donor
    My name is amit from delhi. Regarding kidney donation I contacted dr jonson francis John from uk.his email= ukjohsonkidneydonor2000@gmail.com. mobile number= +2347052619502. He is world no. Fruad and cheater. He cheat me till 2600$. He jist destroy my life. He big scammer. Dont contact him otherwise you will b cheated as me. He is mother fucker cheater. I have deposited all money in indian bank account. I have all bank diposit slip. He is big scammer only. First he told me registered fee. Atfer remittance fee again imf fee again non citzon fee again abusive fee. Really he is big cheater.i have paid him 2100$ till still he wan more money. Now not replying me and not attending my phon. I was in problem so did big mistak. I borrow all money and paid him now I am facing like hell here but cheater not replying me now..
    This amount I paid him his agent account.....
    Date 10/11/2014
    1.Ranbir thakur
    20228082578 SBI. 15000 INR
    2 lawchon
    33916621550 SBI. 16000 INR

    Date 18/11/2014

    3. Sayyad door
    3059340086. SBI. Amount 15000 INR.
    4. Langman
    34007350081 SBI. Amount 16000 INR.

    Date 10/11/2014
    5. Hazari
    20196638653 SBI. Amount 25000 INR

    Date 12/01/2015
    6. Mr. Mantithang
    34143083914 SBI. Amount 10000INR

    Date 13/02/2015.
    7. Mr. S. Jacob
    4768108000233 kanara bank 15000 INR

    Date 23/01/2015
    8. Thanghogin
    20191208943 SBI amount 18500 INR.
    This is all accounts holder and bank account number which I diposited money. Thats is true. I have all diposited slip. If anyone wan to see then contact me my email amit38737@gmail.com. reallybhebis big fruad cheater monther fucker scammer dont contact him to sell your kidney is big cheater.

    ReplyDelete